loading

Tafsir Surah Al-Fatiha: The Opening - Verse 4 - Why does God Test us?

مَالِكِ يَوْمِ الدِّينِ



(Download video)

(Download audio)

Session 15

Chapter 1

Verse 4

The Owner of the Day of Recompense.

(Chapter 1: Verse 4)

If all of God's bounties warrant praise, then the bounty of "the Day of Recompense" deserves a greater praise, because if the Day of Resurrection did not exist, then anyone who filled the world with corruption would escape without being held accountable.  Also, anyone who adhered to justice and deprived him or herself of various worldly enjoyments for God's pleasure would have worked in vain.  By establishing the Day of Judgment, God brought balance and justice to the entire existence.  The fact that there will be an afterlife - in essence, a Day of Reckoning - protects the rights of the weak and prevents the world from turning into a jungle where the strong endlessly attack and tyrannize the weak.

Have you noticed how the corrupt actions of a person don't impact only the victim of these actions?  They actually affect society as a whole.  For example, even if you were not directly affected by the actions of a thief, you may start to feel unsafe when you hear about thefts in your neighborhood.  Here, the verse under study brings a sense of balance as you become aware that the hereafter is awaiting those who have no regard for people's rights in society.  No one will be able to escape that Day regardless of his or her current power and influence.

Similarly, the integrity of a believer benefits the entire society.  When a person fears God, respects everyone's rights, pardons, and forgives, everyone that surrounds him or her benefits from this noble character and stands for truth and equality.  The society as a whole becomes a better place. 

This verse has two different recitals مالك يوم الدين  and ملك يوم الدين.  They differ by only one vowel and are both valid ways of reciting "The Opening" Chapter.  These readings translate to "Owner of the Day of Resurrection" and "King of the Day of Resurrection," respectively.  Let's take them one by one.

God describes Himself in the Quran as the "Owner of the Day of Recompense."  The true owner of something is alone responsible for managing it.  No one else has the right to interfere.  I own my clothes, car, and home; therefore, I am responsible for these items, and I can do as I please with them.  The expression "King of the Day of Recompense," on the other hand, implies that, that Day, God will directly judge the affairs of the people regardless of and beyond their authority in this world.  In this world, God may grant temporary rule and sovereignty over a kingdom to a person or a group, but in the hereafter the rule and command will be His alone, as stated in this verse:

Say: "O Allah, Master of all sovereignty!  You give sovereignty to whomever You wish, and strip of sovereignty whomever You wish; You make mighty whomever You wish, and You abase whomever You wish.  All good is in Your hand.  Indeed You have power over all things." (3:26)

Note that God used the phrase "strip of sovereignty" rather than "take sovereignty," implying that no one in this world wants to give up power willingly; instead, it has to be forcefully withdrawn from him or her.

Here you may question, doesn't rule and control at all time - in this world and the hereafter - belong to God?  The answer is simply yes.  However, God appoints some of His creation as successors and grants them authority on earth as He says in the Quran:               

Have you thought of the man who argued with Abraham about his Lord because God had given him a kingdom?  When Abraham said, "My Lord is the giver of life and death," he replied, "I am the giver of life and death." And Abraham said, "God makes the sun rise from the East.  So make it rise from the West," and dumbfounded was the infidel.  God does not guide those who are unjust.  (2:258)

As you can see, true rule and sovereignty do not stem from the person who governs; rather, they are the result of God's will.  If rule had stemmed from one's self, then power would have remained with him or her forever without changing hands.  Be always mindful that many people are put to the test through this type of grant because God will take rulers to account on the Day of Resurrection.  How did they rule and carry their conduct?  What did they do with their power?  More importantly, people who were ruled are also tested regarding their behavior.  Did they remain silent about an unjust ruler?  Did they prefer corruption?  Or did they stand for the truth?

At first glance, you may get the impression that God is testing us so He will gain the knowledge of who is corrupt and who is upright.  But this could not be farther from the truth: God is our Creator, and He is all-knowledgeable, all-aware of His creation.  Then, you may ask, why does He test us?  He tests us so that we may bear witness against ourselves.  No one can come on the Day of Resurrection and say, "Lord, if only You had given me a chance, I would have followed the right path and implemented your guidelines." To further clarify this point, let's take an example from everyday life.  Universities all over the world conduct exams for their students.  Are the professors who taught these students all year unaware of what their students know?  Do they intend to obtain this knowledge through the exam?  Of course not!  Every teacher can tell you who will ace the test and who will fail well before the examination.  Testing is necessary because it presents the evidence to the students themselves.  If a student fails and then comes to argue, all the teacher has to do is pointing to the test result.  On the other hand, if the exam was not conducted, every student can claim that he or she deserves high grades and honors.

To summarize, if you choose to recite "Owner of the Day of Resurrection," you testify that God will run the affairs of that Day as He desires, without interference at any level.  And, if you recite "King of the Day of Resurrection," you testify that God will judge the affairs of His creations, even those whom He had temporarily made kings and rulers in this world.  God wants to reassure you that, if you had been afflicted by a governor or king, a tyrant or a dictator, then a Day will come where there will be no owner and no king but God Himself.

Now, let's turn our attention to the word "day."  Astronomically a day begins from sunrise until the next sun rise.  Linguistically, in Arabic, "day" is an adverb of time in which events take place.  Since the adverb of time cannot be owned, some scholars explain that the verse "Owner of the Day of Resurrection" indicates the owner of the affairs and events of that Day, rather than the owner of the Day itself.  We reply that this is according to our abilities and understanding as humans because we cannot possess time.  We cannot bring back the past, nor can we bring on the future.  But God Almighty is the Creator of time, and He is not restricted by time or place.  God Almighty states:

They will challenge you to hasten the punishment.  God will not fail in His promise - a Day with your Lord is like a thousand years by your reckoning.  (22:47)

And, in another verse:

The angels and the Spirit ascend to Him in a Day whose length is fifty thousand years.  (70:4)

As you consider these two verses, you quickly recognize the intended meaning of the word "day."  God is the Creator of time; therefore, He can create a day the duration of which is twenty-four hours, and a day the duration of which is a thousand, fifty-thousand, or one million years.  We identify a day as twenty-four hours, subdivided into day and night.  But the fact is that day and night always exist on earth.  As the earth rotates, every minute movement signals the end of a day in a region the beginning of one in another.  Thus, if you view our planet as a whole, you will realize that the day on earth never ends, neither does the night.  Even on our own planet, the succession of days and nights is a relative phenomenon.